Buy a Toyota Highlander from one of its best years instead of one of its worst. The analysis below shows you which Toyota Highlander years you should avoid.
Midsize crossover SUVs have been dominated by Toyota Highlanders.
It is reliable, comfortable, and has well-rounded features, but it has experienced highs and lows over the years.
Toyota Highlander years are analyzed in this manual, offering a comprehensive assessment for prospective buyers.
It’s time to get started.
Toyota Highlander Generations
Generation | Years |
Toyota Highlander (XU70, 4th generation) | 2020 to Present |
Toyota Highlander (XU50, 3rd generation) | 2014 to 2019 |
Toyota Highlander (XU40, 2nd generation) | 2008 to 2013 |
Toyota Highlander (XU20, 1st generation) | 2001 to 2007 |
With the table above, you can see how the Toyota Highlander has evolved over the years. It is likely that a buyer’s decision is greatly influenced by the differences between each generation in terms of design, functionality, and technology.
A “Neutral Year” is one in which there is no significant deviation from the established norm. It’s not the kind of year that surprises with exceptional features or disappoints with pronounced issues.
It would be more accurate to call them average years.
Toyota Highlander Best, Neutral, and Worst Years
Generation | Best Years | Neutral Years | Worst Years |
4th (2020-Present) | 2020 | 2021 | 20222023 |
3rd (2014-2019) | 2014201620172018 | 2015 | 2019 |
2nd (2008-2013) | 200920112012 | 2013 | 20082010 |
1st (2001-2007) | 2003200420052006 | 2002 | 20012007 |
A dozen of hours were spent researching a variety of factors, including owner-reported reliability scores, maintenance costs, safety ratings, Consumer Reports reliability scores, NHTSA recalls, investigation, complaints, Edmunds, JD Power, Kelley’s Blue Book (KBB), VehicleHistory, and Cars.com owner ratings.
Rankings can be negatively affected by certain factors. The number of NHTSA recalls for a model year can indicate lower reliability, thus lowering its score.
We will now examine the Best & Worst Toyota Highlander Years of each generation as a result of the classifications we have made.
Best & Worst Years For Toyota Highlander 4th Generation [2020 to Present]
With the fourth-generation Highlander, released in 2020, the design was further refined and advanced tech features were added.
2020 is the best year
With a suite of driver assistance features, an upscale interior, and a robust V6 engine, the 2020 model set a high standard for the new generation.
A stylish exterior and a quieter cabin were also added to the redesign, enhancing the overall appeal of the vehicle. This year’s Highlander Hybrid, offering impressive fuel economy, is what truly differentiates it from its predecessor.
2021 is the neutral year
Despite remaining a strong midsize SUV competitor, the 2021 Highlander offered no substantial improvements over its predecessor.
Even though it scored highly in safety tests and had a comfortable interior, some complaints about its finicky infotainment system caused it to fall into the neutral category.
2022 and 2023 are the worst years
This model year has received some criticism despite being relatively new. Many owners reported issues with the infotainment system, including freezing screens and automatic reboots.
Further mechanical issues were reported with the braking system and transmission, leading to their placement in the “worst” category.
Best & Worst Years For Toyota Highlander 3rd Generation [2014 to 2019]
Introducing the third-generation Highlander in 2014, it offered increased power and advanced safety features.
The best years were 2014, 2016, 2017, and 2018
The interior quality of these models was upscale and they excelled in reliability and performance. With the introduction of a more efficient transmission, the Highlander’s fuel economy improved and its technology features became more user-friendly.
A Toyota Safety Sense package, which includes pre-collision warnings and lane departure warnings, was another plus.
2015 is the neutral year
There were no significant advancements or problems with the 2015 Highlander. In terms of quality, it maintained the high standards set by the 2014 model, but it was not able to surpass them.
The ride quality and informationtainment system glitches hindered its otherwise good reputation.
The worst year was 2019
Some criticism has been leveled at the 2019 model for its relatively less engaging driving experience and some transmission issues, including abrupt shifts and occasional delays.
The vehicle’s drawbacks led to a lower ranking despite its premium interior and numerous standard safety features.
Best & Worst Years For Toyota Highlander 2nd Generation [2008 to 2013]
Introducing in 2008, the second-generation Highlander was larger, more family-friendly, and more spacious.
The best years were 2009, 2011, and 2012
Three-row seating and high reliability made the 2009, 2011, and 2012 models perfect for larger families.
Power and fuel efficiency were excellently balanced with the introduction of a more powerful 3.5-liter V6 engine in these years. Their appeal was further enhanced by enhanced safety features such as traction control and an improved crash safety rating.
2013 is the neutral year
The 2013 model was generally reliable and offered plenty of interior space, but it did not stand out from other years.
This model year’s low ranking was primarily due to minor issues with the electric power steering and occasional transmission issues.
The worst years were 2008 and 2010
Engine issues such as excessive oil consumption plagued the 2008 model, which marked the beginning of the second generation.
There was also a problem with the interior electronics, including a malfunctioning navigation system and problems with the climate control system. In addition to premature brake wear, the 2010 model had reported problems with body integrity as well.
Best & Worst Years For Toyota Highlander 1st Generation [2001 to 2007]
First introduced in 2001, the Highlander is a dependable, comfortable midsize SUV from Toyota.
2003, 2004, 2005, 2006 are the best years
With exceptional reliability, comfort, and roomy cargo space, these were the peak years for the first generation.
2004 marked the introduction of the 3.3-liter V6 engine, which increased power and fuel efficiency while improving towing capability.
Furthermore, safety features such as airbags and stability control systems were enhanced in these years.
2002 was a neutral year
In terms of reliability and performance, the 2002 model was decent. In spite of these issues, the engine was able to score a “best” rating due to a coolant leak and an oxygen sensor failure.
This vehicle’s minor drawbacks were counterbalanced by its strengths, such as ample interior space and a comfortable ride.
The worst years were 2001 and 2007
There were several issues with the 2001 model, including transmission problems and air conditioning system failures. The company’s initial reputation was tarnished by these issues, leading to a spike in owner reports of problems.
2007 was an uninspiring year for this generation because of its subpar interior quality and uninspired handling.
Common Issues With The Toyota Highlander
The Toyota Highlander years have some common problems that you should avoid.
Engine Bolts Becoming Stripped
Unless you catch the issue early, this can become a serious problem. Typically, coolant leaks and overheating engines are the first signs of stripped engine bolts.
If needed, you can replace the bolts and re-drill the holes in the bolts if overheating has not already damaged your engine. Most people who encountered this problem had to replace their engines completely.
A car with 130k miles on it is most likely to experience this issue, but it can recur after the first time it occurs.
Engine Failure
In general, Toyota Highlanders have a high rate of engine failure. In those cases, the engine bolts are probably stripped, causing overheating issues, but other issues can also occur.
In other words, if you buy a Toyota Highlander from a problem year, you’re more likely to have to replace your engine.
It’s also worth considering if you have the resources to replace your engine and if you would likely need a new car if your engine failed, since engine failure is a problem only some car owners are willing to address.
There are some cases where engine failure occurs slightly before 120k miles, but it is more common around 120k miles. Several Highlanders will make it to 120k miles without any problems, but later on they may experience problems.
Using Engine Oil Faster Than Average
The Toyota Highlander is unfortunately one of those vehicles that consumes oil. Almost any model of Highlander can have this problem, but it’s more common with older models.
It’s interesting to note that 2002 is the worst model year for burning through engine oil. You shouldn’t worry too much about this problem in a 2002 Highlander if you’re okay with paying a little extra for oil. It may be more problematic if you’re considering another model year with other known issues.
Fuel Tank and AC Condenser Problems
There were a couple of reliability issues with the redesigned 2020 Highlander, although critics and consumers generally liked it. It was reported that the fuel tank on the 2020 model had issues.
It was claimed that they were unable to fill the tank to its advertised capacity of 17.1 gallons. In the end, they were only able to fill up about 12-14 gallons of gas.
The Highlander’s AC system has also been reported to be hit or miss in several reports. According to reports, the AC condenser was susceptible to damage, resulting in the AC not blowing cool air. Replacement of the condenser, including labor, may cost between $60 and $150.
Faulty Head Gasket and Oxygen Sensor
Highlander models from 2001-2007 are prone to engine overheating. It appears that a blown head gasket is causing the engine to overheat. The head bolts tend to pull out the threads from the engine block, eventually blowing the head gasket.
There have also been reports of faulty oxygen sensors on several Highlander models. Misfiring and rough idling are caused by this defect.
Which Models Of Toyota Highlander Are Great To Buy Used?
There are a lot of good used options on the list we’ve provided, but there are some that are better than others. Our recommendation would be the 2010 model if you’re looking for a good deal and want a model that’s a little larger and more spacious than others. There are also a few more problem reports for models between 2009 and 2011.
For those looking for a more recent model and aren’t concerned about the price, 2016 models, 2017 models, and 2018 models are all excellent values. For now, we can’t recommend the 2019 or 2020 models as used vehicles, but they appear to be viable options when it comes to used vehicles.
Read: Best & Worst Jeep Wrangler Years
Read: Best & Worst Toyota Corolla Years
Read: Best & Worst Subaru Forester Years
Read: Best & Worst Toyota Camry Years
Read: Best & Worst Honda Civic Years
Read: Best & Worst Toyota RAV4 Years
Frequently Asked Questions
What Toyota Highlander years should I avoid in the used car market?
If you are considering purchasing a Toyota Highlander, you should avoid those from the years 2003, 2008, 2014, and 2015. A greater number of issues have been identified with these models than with other years.
Were there any Toyota Highlander models with notable engine problems?
In some Toyota Highlander models, engine bolts became stripped, leading to coolant leaks, overheating, and, in some cases, complete engine replacements. There were a lot of these problems around 130,000 miles.
Has Toyota addressed the fuel tank issue in the 2020 Highlander model?
It has been acknowledged that Toyota’s 2020 Highlander’s fuel tank could not be filled to its advertised capacity due to a problem with the fuel tank. It may be necessary for dealers to check for and rectify any anomalies in fuel tank assemblies or design.
Which model years offer the best balance between cost and reliability for a used Toyota Highlander?
A good balance between cost and reliability can be found in models from 2001, 2005, 2006, 2007, and 2009 through 2013, as well as more recent models from 2017 to 2021. It is generally considered to be a good investment to purchase models from these years since they do not suffer from the serious issues that plagued other models.
Are Toyota Highlanders typically reliable?
In the U.S., the Highlander has been a trusted family hauler for over 20 years thanks to Toyota’s reputation for dependability. Toyota Highlander years 2003, 2008, 2014, and 2015 should be avoided, but most models are reliable.
How much does a used Toyota Highlander typically cost?
Older Highlanders, such as those from 2002 with 100,000 miles, cost about $6,000. The prices of newer examples, however, rise rapidly due to their high demand. For a 2012 Highlander, expect to pay double or triple this amount, depending on its condition and equipment. There is a tight market, which results in almost-new Highlanders having new car prices. The asking price of a 2020 Toyota Highlander is $38,158 according to CoPilot Price Pulse. At normal times, the car would sell for 17% less.
Is the Toyota Highlander a good car to purchase?
Absolutely. Three-row crossovers like the Toyota Highlander are excellent choices. They are a safe investment as used cars because most model years have good reliability (here are the most reliable Toyota Highlander years). If you’re buying a new Highlander, a warranty will give you extra peace of mind.
Conclusion
Over the years, the Toyota Highlander has shown an intricate, but overall impressive evolution. You can make better purchasing decisions if you know which years are the best and worst for the model.
It highlights the Toyota Highlander’s best and worst years based on reliability, maintenance, safety, and consumer satisfaction.
What is your favorite model year of the Toyota Highlander? Feel free to leave a comment below with your answer.